Dignity + SAVE: A Compromise Neither Side Can Dismiss
“We lock federal elections to documentary proof of U.S. citizenship — and we stabilize long-term undocumented residents through an earned, heavily verified legal status that is not citizenship.”
Translation: election certainty for the security crowd, lawful order for the compassion crowd, and no “free pass” for anybody.
For the Election Integrity / Rule-of-Law Side
Your non-negotiables: no loopholes, no identity games, no “trust me” elections, no benefits pipeline, no stealth citizenship.
What you get (hard guarantees)
- Federal voter registration requires documentary proof of U.S. citizenship — no ambiguity, no vibes, no “it’ll probably be fine.”
- Uniform federal standard for eligibility proof so states aren’t improvising a patchwork that fuels mistrust.
- Clear enforcement posture: knowingly registering non-citizens for federal elections becomes a compliance failure with consequences.
What you do not concede (the line stays where you want it)
- No automatic pathway to citizenship from the long-term legalization track.
- No “paper-only” identity: identity verification is the spine of the system, not an optional checkbox.
- No fraud tolerance: fake docs, ID mills, or program gaming = disqualification and prosecution triggers.
The pressure-point rebuttal you usually hear — handled upfront
“This is amnesty and they’ll vote.”
No. The legal status offered is not citizenship, and federal voter registration is gated by proof of citizenship.
The whole point is to end the argument, not recycle it every election cycle.
For the Compassion / Human Reality Side
Your non-negotiables: no mass-deportation theater, no permanent underclass, no exploitation economy, no citizens harmed by bureaucracy.
What you get (stability with accountability)
- Earned legal status for long-term undocumented residents who can verify identity, pass background checks, and follow a clear compliance track.
- Economic integration with enforcement: bring workers into taxable, regulated employment instead of forcing cash-labor shadow markets.
- Conditional, revocable status: serious crime, fraud, or repeated violations terminate status — accountability is real.
Citizen safeguards (so election rules don’t become collateral damage)
- Clear list of acceptable citizenship documents for federal registration (no guessing games).
- Free/fast replacement pathways so citizens missing paperwork aren’t locked out by cost or distance.
- Grace periods + appeals for clerical errors so eligible citizens aren’t punished for bureaucracy.
The pressure-point rebuttal you usually hear — handled upfront
“This is voter suppression and cruelty.”
No. It’s citizenship verification with guardrails for citizens — and immigration stabilization that replaces fear and exploitation with enforceable order.
The Shared Foundation (the part both sides secretly want)
- Citizenship is sacred. Voting in federal elections is for citizens — provably.
- Compassion without verification is chaos. Verification without compassion is cruelty.
- End two black markets at once: disputed registration and underground labor.
- No one gets a free pass. Everyone gets a clear process, and violations have consequences.
How to Phrase “Non-Sovereignly Go Back” Without It Exploding
If your intent is “not mass removals as the default,” say it like this:
- Voluntary return pathways with lawful re-entry options where appropriate — paired with strict identity controls.
- Targeted enforcement for violent crime, trafficking, fraud rings, and repeat offenders.
- Earned status for the long-term, clean-record population that passes checks and stays compliant.
This is not “open borders.” It’s triage + control: prioritize real threats, stabilize the rest, and stop pretending chaos is policy.
The One-Paragraph Pitch (for rooms where people interrupt)
Pair election certainty with immigration order: require documentary proof of U.S. citizenship for federal voter registration — period. And create a Dignity-style earned legal status for long-term undocumented residents who verify identity, pass strict background checks, pay taxes/fees, and maintain good standing — with no automatic citizenship lane and firm fraud/crime disqualifiers. That secures elections, shrinks the underground economy, reduces exploitation, and restores enforceable control.
Comments
Post a Comment